Andrea Floyd
ENGL 112 b
May, 2nd,
2007
Unit Plan
Discovering American
Poetry:
Reading and Writing to
the Beat
Perhaps
the greatest difficulty educators face when attempting to excite students about
poetry is the fact that most teens write off poetry before they become well
acquainted with the genre. As
documented in Dr. Mary L. Warner�s book Adolescents in the Search for Meaning,
where she surveys 1400 teens on their views regarding young adult literature,
only 0.4% of her participants cited poetry as a genre of literature they found
helpful in their lives (Warner 38).
Generally speaking, teens find literature they perceive as inaccessible
or hard to understand not worth the effort of investigating. Poetry can be challenging; however,
students will only benefit from taking a closer look at all that poetry has to
offer. Poetry is a uniquely
special genre of literature for it strongly encourages individual
interpretation. When studying and
deciphering poetry, no answer is incorrect that is supported and thoughtfully
given. Poetry elicits personal
expression, whether it be through writing or analyzing poetry. Language Arts teacher Tamara L. C. Van
Wyhe, in her essay titled �Remembering What is Important: The Power of Poetry in
my Classroom,� writes of �How important it is to see past the textbook
interpretations and scripted questions,� when teaching poetry. This fact may add to the difficulty
students find within the genre of poetry; however, it equally adds to its
literary power.
I
propose a unit that equally stresses both the reading and writing of
poetry. Students who are great
readers, become skilled writers and student writers, become more critical
readers. The core objectives of
this unit are to orient students with poetic techniques while simultaneously
studying the work of Ginsberg and the Beatniks. Writing exercises play an integral role and will be a daily
occurrence. Unlocking the poet
within the student will lead to a higher level of critical thinking when reading
poetry.
Launching the Unit
This unit
centers on the study of the Beat Generation and ultimately, a close look at
Allen Ginsberg�s work �Howl.� The
rudimentary phases of the unit however, will focus on writing and recognizing
poetry on a daily basis in an attempt to answer a question that has no concrete
answer: What is Poetry?
1. Ask students
to bring in a copy of song lyrics that they consider poetic. Lyrics may be taken from various
genres, from classic rock to rap.
Students must be prepared to share why they chose their song and what
they recognize as poetic within song�s lyrics.
Questions to
consider when discussing song lyrics:
� In what ways do you find these lyrics
poetic?
� Do elements such as rhyme or rhythm
affect the words of the song?
� Who is the speaker? Is the artist or musician speaking from
his or her own point of view, or someone else�s? This question is a good way to introduce the ideas of voice
and point of view in poetry
� When read aloud, without the accompanying
music, are the words still powerful?
2. Using
newspapers, magazines and various forms of print media, have students cut out
words they find striking and arrange them to create a found poem. Found poems may be as random or
organized as the students wish.
Allow students to create their found poems about any subject, or give
them a topic that will bring multiple interpretations, such as, describing a
place.
3. Have students
write a list poem. Instruct
students to begin their first ten lines with the phrase �I will never,� listing
thoughts, actions, or emotions they feel aptly complete the line. On the eleventh and final line, have
students begin with the phrase �I will always.� Encourage students to share their pieces with the
class. An interesting way to
further this activity is to take a line from each students� pieces, without
identifying the author, and type up a group list poem to share with students
the following day.
4. Watch the clip from the Robin
Williams film Dead Poets Society where the textbook definition of poetry is
read. After reading this highly
technical and mathematical definition of poetry, Williams� character instructs
his students to tear these pages out of their books. Discuss this scene with students. Why does the professor ask his students to tear the
definition out? Ask whether they
feel poetry can truly be defined.
After discussion, have students do a quick free write expressing their
reactions to the clip and how they would define poetry.
Allen Ginsberg and The
Beatniks
Ginsberg�s
�Howl� created a wave of cultural change that influenced not only literature,
but also the art world, popular culture, and media. Rarely does a piece of literature inflict as great an impact
as �Howl� has. This may be
difficult for students to grasp. To
contextualize, spark an open discussion with students encouraging them to share
what they know about American ideals during the early 1950�s. What was considered acceptable, decent,
and moral? Have them ponder the
various forms of evidence that shape their opinions, including their knowledge
of American history, as well as what they�ve read, heard, or viewed through
pertinent forms of media such as film or television.
When
first published in 1956 by
Lawrence Ferlinghetti�s City Lights Bookstore, �Howl� was seized for violating
obscenity laws. The courts
eventually allowed Ferlinghetti to continue publishing �Howl,� but many
Americans continued to view Ginsberg work offensive and threatening to
traditional American values. �Howl� cannot be discussed without tackling the
idea of censorship, an issue still prevalent in American life.
�Howl�
major themes include alienation, race, conformity, sexuality, and insanity,
issues teens are still well acquainted with today. Discuss these themes with students. What elements of the poem evoke these
sentiments? What elements of their
lives today also bring forth these issues. �Howl� is a very long poem and some content is not
appropriate for a high school classroom.
I suggest tactfully reading the poem aloud to students. The lyrical strength strong voice
within the piece will resonate.
After
reading and discussing �Howl,�
listen to the song �I Should Be Allowed to Think� by the band They Might
Be Giants. The song takes
Ginsberg�s moving first line, �I saw the best minds of my generation destroyed
by madness, starving, hysterical naked,� and continues with their own take
(Ginsberg 131). Aside from the
first line, ask students to think about how �Howl� influences the song. What similarities or difference do they
find. This activity sets the stage
for one of the units final projects.
Extending the Unit
One
way to extend study of the Beat Movement is to have students read works from
other notable Beat writers. One of
the unique characteristics of the Beat Movement is the fact its influence
appears in a variety of literary works, extending well beyond the genre of
poetry. Some accompanying works
include Jack Kerouac�s On the Road, Ken Kesey�s One Flew Over the Cuckoo�s
Nest, and although considered a difficult read for many, William S. Burroughs�
Naked Lunch. When reading these
selections, have students identify motifs within the texts characteristic of
the Beat Movement. What themes
tend to reoccur? Connections may
be drawn through stylistic, political, or ideological elements. Furthermore, can connections be
made to Ginsberg and his work specifically?
To
extend understanding of how significant the influence of Ginsberg�s �Howl�
continues to be, have students go on a �Literary Hunt� for a piece of poetry, prose, or even a
song, they feel connects with the ideas or stylistic elements of the Beat
Movement. In reference to �Howl,�
these pieces may touch on the themes of race, conformity, sexuality, or insanity. Stylistically speaking, students may look
for pieces that exhibit similar poetic elements such as voice, structure,
rhythm, or use of figurative language.
Students must find a work that was created after 1956, the year Ginsberg
penned �Howl.�
To
further the study of poetic devices, have students write an ekphrasis
poem. An ekphrasis poem is a piece
written as a response or reaction to a piece of visual art. There are numerous examples of
ekphrasis pieces within the American canon, including Lawrence Ferlinghetti�s
�[In Goya�s greatest scenes we seem to see].� Assigning an ekphrasis poem is also an ideal way to
collaborate with other classes.
Arrange an art show with the school art teacher and have students write
ekphrasis pieces on student art.
In a week or two, when poems are polished, student poets can hold a
reading and share their pieces with the student artists that inspired them.
Poetry Selections Geared
Towards Young Adults
There are wealth
of poetry resources for young adults out there, including works created by
their fellow teens. Here is just a
portion of some examples. The
following information is taken from amazon.com. A full citation appears in the Works Cited Section.
� Things I Have to Tell You: Poems and
Writings by Teenage Girls, by Betsy Franco Yas, is a collection of writings by
young women which tackles issues such as body image and other pressures teens
face. The poems are illustrated
with black and white photos.
� You Hear Me? Poems and Writings by
Teenage Boys, also by Betsy Franco Yas follows a similar format; however, this
piece is geared towards young men.
� Angst!: Teen Verse From the Edge, by
Karen Tom, contains gritty language and intense subject matter such as drug use
and violence.
� Paint Me Like I Am: Teen Poems From
Writers Corps, by Bill Aguado contains pieces by many disadvantaged youths and
grapples with many issues teens in urban communities are faced with.
Samples of In Class
Writing Activities
� Focusing on simile and metaphor, have
students write a simile or metaphor about themselves. Students should choose one object to compare themselves with
and then begin their poem with �I am� or �I am like.� On the following lines, instruct students to compare
themselves to that object in greater detail, creating an extended simile or
metaphor.
� Write a personification poem. Have students pick one object or animal
and write the object or animal�s point of view. The poem must include sensory details, exhibiting the five
human senses. What does the object
see, hear, feel, smell, and taste?
� Read Susan Mitchell�s poem �The
Dead.� In this piece, Mitchell
writes of what the dead can do that the living cannot. Have students play with this idea and
write a poem about what they think the dead can, or cannot do. Students may even wish to write from
the point of view of the dead.
� This interesting revision technique also
makes for a fun in class activity.
Have students type or write out an extra copy of a poem they have
already written. Then have
students cut up the poem into individual lines and phrases and rearrange their
words. Student poets may find that
some words are unnecessary and choose to cut them out. Also, when rearranging words, students
may discover an entirely new poem.
Concluding Activities
This poetry unit culminates with two
major activities. The first
assignment consists of students rewriting Allen Ginsberg�s �Howl,� from their
point of view, addressing the issues and struggles they feel are prevalent
within their generation, just as Ginsberg did in 1956. After both heightening their writing
skills through the study of stylistic poetic devices and reading the various
works included within this unit, students are expected to produce polished and
thoughtful poems. Encourage
students to explore themes similar to those in Ginsberg�s �Howl,� such as
conformity and other societal issues; however, also encourage them to explore
new avenues. What is key is that
students express what they feel through their personal lens. What do they see? Perhaps their views hold great hope for
the future, nostalgia for the past, or even apathy. To spark this writing assignment, begin with an in class
free write, asking students to ponder the following questions:
� What makes you crazy?
� What brings you joy?
� What frightens, scares, worries you?
� What do you question?
Encourage
students to put sincere thought into their writing, reminding them that when
writing poetry, there are no write or wrong answers, as long as a strong effort
is put forth.
On
the day the assignment is due, rearrange the classroom and create an inviting
setting for a poetry reading. It
is important to create an environment where students feel comfortable sharing
their work throughout the unit, so as to make activities such as a poetry reading
successful and fun. If dealing
with a more timid group, have students break into groups of four or five and
share their writing with group members.
Each group can then pick one or two selections to share in front of the
entire class. Invite other classes
to come and listen, dedicating the day to a celebration of student poetry.
The
second unit ending activity consists of a dramatic poetic performance. Have students select a poem from a
published American poet that is of at least 16 lines in length to memorize and
perform before their classmates.
Students will bring their selection to life through dramatic
interpretation, utilizing expressive elements such as costumes, lighting, or
music. The more creativity
students put into this assignment, the more enjoyable the activity will be for
both performer and audience.
Discuss the use of effective performance and speaking techniques such as
voice, eye contact, and body language with students. Ask them what grabs their attention when they hear someone
read or perform and encourage them to consider such captivating styles within
their own pieces. Again, create an
inviting setting; hang a dramatic backdrop on the wall to set the stage and let
the students do the rest.
Works Cited
30 Apr. 2007 <www.amazon.com>.
Addonizioo, Kim, and Doianne Laux. A
Poet's Companion. New York: W.W. Norton & Company, 1997.
Burroughs, William S. Naked Lunch.
New York: Grove P, 1959.
Dead Poets Society. Dir. Peter
Weir. Perf. Robin Williams. Silver Screen Partners, 1989.
Ginsberg, Allen. "Howl." Postmodern
American Poetry. New York: W.W. Norton & Company, Inc., 1994.
131-135.
Greco, Debbie S. "Introduction to
Poetry." The Educator's Reference Desk. 16 Feb. 1996. 30 Apr. 2007
<http://www.eduref.org/cgi-bin/printlessons.cgi/Virtual/Lessons/Language_Arts/Literature/LIT0008.html>.
Kenneth, Donelson L., and Alleen Pace
Nelso. Literature for Today's Young Adult. 7th ed. Boston: Pearson
Custom, 2005.
Kerouac, Jack. On the Road. New
York: Penguin Books, 1976.
Kesey, Ken. One Flew Over the Cuckoo's
Nest. New York: Signet, 1962.
Kowit, Steven. In the Palm of Your
Hand. Gardiner: Tilbury House, 1995.
L. C. Van Wyhe, Tamara. "Remembering
What is Important: the Power of Poetry in My Classroom." English
Journal 96 (2006): 15-16.
LyricsDepot.Com. 28 Apr. 2007 <http://www.lyricsdepot.com/they-might-be-giants/i-should-be-allowed-to-think.html>.
Moorman, Honor. "Backing Into
Ekphrasis: Reading and Writing Poetry About Visual Art." English
Journal 96 (2006): 46-53.
"The Beat Movement." 28 Apr.
2007 <www.rooknet.com/beatpage/index.html>.
Tsujimoto, Joseph I. Teaching Poetry
Writing to Adolescents. Urbana: ERIC Clearinghouse on Reading and
Communication Skills and the National Council of Teachers of English,
1988.
Warner, Mary L. Adolescents in the
Search for Meaning: Tapping the Powerful Resource of Story. Latham: The
Scarecrow P, Inc., 2006.