applet-magic.com Thayer Watkins Silicon Valley & Tornado Alley USA |
---|
|
One factor which has made it difficult for South Korea to weather financially troubled times is that the major corporations of South Korea have linked themselves together financially. These linkages are not motivated by financial self-interest but instead are dictated by family relationship and comradery.
In December of 1997 Halla, then the 12th largest chaebol of South Korea, went bankrupt. Its debt/equity ratio was about twenty to one. This bankruptcy cost Hyundai, the largest chaebol, about $1 billion. The lost could be even more because Hyundai guaranteed some of the debts of Halla. Hyundai's loans and support of Halla was not based upon any assessment of the risk and returns for Halla debt. Instead it was based up family relationship, the head of Halla was the brother of the head of Hyundai.
Chaebol are family businesses. This means male members of the family get to run businesses. If they do not have the abilities necessary to be part of the main company subsidiaries are set up for them to run. For example, a relative of the leadership of the Samsung operates a soft-drink company. The vending machines in the Samsung buildings stock those soft drinks.
The linkages between chaebol are not limited to family relations. There is a perplexity propensity of Korean firms to make nationalism more important than profitability. It is perhaps a holdover of the feudalistic and tribalistic mentality in Korean culture.
A chaebol is a collection of firms. There may be one or a few main firms within the colllection which are making most of the profits. The financial health of the main firms may seem sound but when the consolidated accounts of the entire chaebol are compiled the profit may largely or entirely disappear. The entire chaebol may be operating at a loss even though the main firm is comfortably profitable.
The chaebol have been so heavily involved in loan-guarantee practices that the South Korean legislature found it necessary to restrict chaebol's loan guarantee to no more than the amount of their equities.
The government tries to restict the loans between chaebol, but the chaebol have found ways aroung the government restrictions. They did using the following strategems:
It is seemingly strange that the South Korean legislature has found it advisable to tell the chaebol that they should be more concerned with profitability and that in making loans they should be more concerned with the risks involved for themselves. It is not so strange as it seems if one recognizes that, as a remnant of the feudal and tribalistic culture, Koreans treat business like a military operation. Someone running an army needs to be concerned about getting the proper level of funds but it makes no difference whatsoever where those funds come from. A quasi-militaristic enterprise is glad to get profits but if the profits are not forthcoming it will seek government grants and loans without hesitation. A quasi-militaristic firm will also provide aid to comrade-in-arms firms when they need it and expect the same from them when it needs it.
HOME PAGE OF Thayer Watkins |